Manchester City Challenges Premier League’s Redrafted Finance Rules
Manchester City has sent a strongly-worded letter to Liverpool, Everton, and all other Premier League clubs, expressing concerns over the revised Associated Party Transaction (APT) rules. The letter claims the proposed amendments are “unlawful” and urges clubs to reconsider their support.
Landmark Commission Ruling
In October, a landmark commission ruling concluded that while APT regulation was necessary, certain aspects of the framework breached EU competition law. Both Manchester City and the Premier League claimed victory, but the ruling necessitated adjustments to the Premier League’s rules.
Contentious Letter
Man City’s chief lawyer, Simon Cliff, has written to Premier League clubs, arguing that the newly-drafted proposals still contravene the commission’s judgment. Cliff’s letter highlights significant concerns with the revised rules.
Unlawful Rules and Rushed Consultation
Cliff accuses the Premier League of rushing through the consultation process, leaving clubs to “vote blind” without fully understanding the implications. He also believes the revised APT rules remain non-compliant with EU competition law.
Implications of Man City’s Letter
The letter’s implications are significant, potentially delaying or blocking the rule changes. Other clubs may share similar concerns, leading to a divided vote, and escalating into a larger conflict between Man City and the Premier League.
Upcoming Vote
Premier League clubs will vote on the revised APT rules next week. Man City’s letter aims to influence the outcome and spark meaningful discussion.
Premier League Response
The Premier League has not publicly responded to Man City’s letter. However, the organization may address the concerns before the vote to alleviate any doubts.
Man City’s Stance
By challenging the revised rules, Man City demonstrates its commitment to ensuring fair competition and adherence to regulatory frameworks. The club’s proactive approach may prompt other clubs to reevaluate their stance.
Liverpool and Everton’s Response
It remains to be seen how Liverpool and Everton will react to Man City’s letter and whether they will support or oppose the revised APT rules. Their responses will be crucial in determining the outcome of the vote.
A Critical Moment for Premier League
The dispute surrounding the APT rules has brought attention to the Premier League’s governance and regulatory framework. The outcome of the vote will have far-reaching implications for the league’s future.
