New Orleans Saints QB Derek Carr. The proposed deal would involve a 2025 fourth-round pick and a conditional 2026 draft pick. Carr, a four-time Pro Bowler, has two years remaining on a two-year, $150 million extension, with a $51.4 million cap hit in 2025 and $61.4 million in 2026.
While Carr has a no-trade clause, the argument is that he might be willing to waive it for a chance to play under Mike Tomlin, one of the most respected coaches in the league. The move could help the Saints clear salary cap space while allowing Pittsburgh to add a steady veteran presence at quarterback.
Analysis
Pros of the Trade for the Steelers
Proven Quarterback: Carr is a four-time Pro Bowler with experience leading teams to the playoffs.
Stable Presence: Unlike younger, unproven QBs, Carr offers a reliable option who can help maximize the Steelers’ offensive weapons (e.g., George Pickens).
Mike Tomlin’s Influence: Tomlin has never had a losing season, and his leadership could make Pittsburgh an appealing destination for Carr.
Better Option than Free Agents? With Wilson and Fields hitting free agency, Pittsburgh could struggle to find a better, affordable alternative.
Cons of the Trade for the Steelers
High Salary Cap Hit: Paying $51.4 million in 2025 would severely limit the Steelers’ ability to upgrade other key positions.
Limited Upside: Carr is solid but has never been a top-tier QB; he might not elevate Pittsburgh to true Super Bowl contention.
Blocking Future Growth: Acquiring Carr could prevent Pittsburgh from drafting or developing a young QB.
Pros of the Trade for the Saints
Salary Cap Relief: New Orleans is in a difficult cap situation, and moving Carr would clear room to rebuild.
Draft Capital: A fourth-round pick plus a conditional pick in 2026 would help stockpile future assets.
Cons of the Trade for the Saints
Lack of a QB Replacement: If the Saints trade Carr, they would need to find a new starter immediately, whether through the draft or free agency.
Final Verdict: Should the Steelers Trade for Derek Carr?
If Pittsburgh only wants a short-term veteran QB to keep the team competitive, Carr makes sense.
If they want a long-term franchise QB, they should explore younger options via the draft or other trades.
The high salary cap hit is a major concern, making this deal a risky move for the Steelers.
If Pittsburgh can negotiate a salary reduction or contract restructure, acquiring Carr could be worthwhile—but otherwise, they may be better off sticking with a younger, more affordable quarterback.
