The New Orleans Saints are experiencing renewed excitement with the draft of rookie quarterback Tyler Shough, taken 40th overall. This comes shortly before the retirement announcement of presumed starter Derek Carr, potentially opening the door for Shough to take over right away. In an interview, Shough shared his early impressions of New Orleans, expressing enthusiasm for the city and its culture.
He also reflected on his unexpected selection by the Saints and his struggles with injuries during college. Despite the optimism, Pro Football Focus has ranked Shough as the worst starting quarterback in the league, citing low expectations for the Saints’ quarterback situation.
By the Numbers
Tyler Shough was selected by the Saints with the 40th overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft.
Pro Football Focus ranked him as the 32nd starting quarterback in the league heading into the season.
Yes, But
While Shough brings potential and excitement to the Saints, his ranking as the worst quarterback raises concerns about the team’s overall effectiveness. There are mixed perspectives surrounding Shough’s ability to lead a team, especially following his struggles in college and the pressure of stepping in during a transition period.
State of Play
Shough is acclimating to life in New Orleans and preparing for possible starting duties in week one.
The quarterback room has been criticized for its lack of strength, with Shough viewed as one of three underwhelming options.
What’s Next
As the offseason progresses, Shough’s performances in training camp and preseason games will be critical in determining his viability as a starter. The Saints need to assess whether he can rise above the expectations as they head into the regular season.
Bottom Line
Rookie quarterback Tyler Shough must navigate the pressure of being thrust into a starting role while overcoming his past injuries. His adaptability and commitment to the team will be crucial as the Saints aim to turn low expectations into success.
