Cleveland’s Quarterback Dilemma: With Only Kenny Pickett Healthy Weeks Before the NFL Draft, Should the Browns Bet on Carson Wentz or Bring Back Joe Flacco for 2025?
As the NFL Draft approaches, the Cleveland Browns find themselves in a precarious position—only one healthy quarterback remains on their roster: Kenny Pickett. With a critical need for depth and experience at the position, the Browns must make a strategic decision: should they pursue a seasoned veteran like Carson Wentz, or bring back last year’s late-season hero, Joe Flacco?
The Case for Carson Wentz
At 31 years old, Carson Wentz remains a high-upside option. The former No. 2 overall pick has experience as both a starter and a backup, most recently with the Los Angeles Rams. While inconsistency has plagued him throughout his career, Wentz still possesses the arm strength, mobility, and playmaking ability that made him an MVP candidate during his prime years with the Philadelphia Eagles. If the Browns are looking for a quarterback who can push Pickett for the starting job while providing a dynamic presence, Wentz could be their best bet.
The Case for Joe Flacco
Bringing back Joe Flacco might be the safer and more sentimental choice for Cleveland. The 39-year-old veteran was instrumental in the Browns’ playoff push last season, stepping in midseason and delivering clutch performances. Flacco’s experience, leadership, and deep-ball accuracy gave Cleveland’s offense a much-needed spark. If the Browns want continuity and a proven mentor for Pickett, re-signing Flacco could be the right move.
What’s the Best Move?
The Browns must weigh their options carefully. If they want a younger, more mobile quarterback with potential upside, Wentz is the clear choice. However, if they value stability, leadership, and a QB who already understands their system, Flacco remains an ideal candidate.
With the NFL Draft less than a month away, Cleveland’s decision at quarterback could shape their 2025 season. Will they roll the dice on Wentz, stick with a familiar face in Flacco, or surprise everyone with another unexpected move? Browns fans are waiting anxiously for the answer.
