MAPLE LEAFS’ MATTHEWS CAUGHT IN LOVE TRIANGLE? Auston Matthews Sparks Rumors with Stunning Hockey Star Mikayla Demaiter
Toronto, April 8, 2025 – Toronto Maple Leafs’ superstar Auston Matthews is no stranger to headlines — whether it’s about his on-ice heroics or his fashion-forward appearances off the rink. But now, the NHL sensation finds himself at the center of an unexpected media whirlwind: a rumored love triangle involving none other than former hockey goalie turned model and influencer, Mikayla Demaiter.
The speculation began brewing after fans noticed a string of subtle but telling interactions between Matthews, 27, and Demaiter, 24, on social media. The two have reportedly exchanged likes and comments on each other’s posts in recent weeks, with eagle-eyed followers pointing to a now-deleted Instagram story of Demaiter attending a Maple Leafs home game at Scotiabank Arena.
Demaiter, known for her viral transition from a professional goalie with the PWHL to becoming a full-time model and influencer, has amassed over 3 million followers on Instagram, where she regularly posts glamorous shots and motivational captions. Her connection to the hockey world remains strong — and that might just be the foundation of this budding (and possibly complicated) relationship.
Whispers of Romance
While neither Matthews nor Demaiter has confirmed any romantic involvement, sources close to both parties say the chemistry between them is “undeniable.” One source, who preferred to remain anonymous, told The Hockey Beat:
“They’ve been talking for a while. It started casually, but things have definitely heated up. They have a lot in common, especially their love for hockey and the lifestyle around it.”
Adding a twist to the story is Matthews’ rumored on-again, off-again relationship with long-time girlfriend Emily Rutledge, a socialite and business graduate based in Arizona, where Matthews grew up. The two have been linked for several years, though their relationship has always remained low-profile and private.
Fans were quick to notice that Matthews and Rutledge have unfollowed each other on Instagram — a modern signal that all may not be well between them.
Media Frenzy and Fan Theories
As expected, the internet has exploded with theories, memes, and hot takes. Some fans have dubbed the unfolding drama “the NHL’s version of The Bachelor,” while others are more critical, calling it a distraction during a crucial playoff push for the Maple Leafs.
Matthews, currently enjoying another stellar season with 45 goals and 38 assists, has yet to comment publicly on the rumors. His representatives have declined requests for comment, and the Leafs’ management is keeping tight-lipped.
Demaiter, on the other hand, has continued to post cryptic captions, including one just days ago that read: “Some connections don’t need labels to be real. 🌹”
Public Reaction: Mixed Emotions
While some fans are giddy over the possibility of a hockey power couple, others worry about potential distractions. Sports radio segments in Toronto have spent countless hours debating the situation, with callers divided between support for Matthews’ personal life and concerns over his focus.
Former Leafs captain and analyst Doug Gilmour weighed in during a panel discussion on TSN:
“Look, Auston’s a professional. Whatever’s going on in his personal life, it won’t shake him. But yeah, when you’re in the spotlight — especially in Toronto — even your dating life becomes headline news.”
What’s Next?
As the Maple Leafs gear up for the playoffs, one thing is clear: all eyes are on Auston Matthews — and not just for his wrist shot.
Whether the rumors with Mikayla Demaiter are just that, or whether the two are genuinely exploring a deeper connection, remains to be seen. For now, fans will have to settle for reading between the lines, zooming in on social media clues, and waiting for either of the stars to make things official.
Until then, the love triangle buzz adds yet another layer to the ongoing saga of one of hockey’s most fascinating figures — on and off the ice.
