Italian media are raising eyebrows over Sandro Tonali’s fluctuating status at Newcastle United. The midfielder, who joined the Magpies for £55 million in 2023, has recently found himself labeled a “reserve” despite a string of transformative performances in the deep-lying midfield role.
Calciomercato compared Tonali’s extensive international involvement with Italy to his rotational usage under Eddie Howe. The 24-year-old has flourished since being shifted to a defensive midfield position, demonstrating his tactical intelligence, precise passing, and athleticism—qualities that initially struggled to shine in his more advanced role.
Despite this, Tonali was benched during Newcastle’s recent 4-2 defeat at Brentford, a decision that frustrated fans. Howe’s reasoning points to squad rotation during a congested fixture schedule, but Tonali’s benching has reignited debates about his long-term role at the club.
Italian fans and media speculate about Tonali’s future, with Calciomercato highlighting AC Milan supporters’ ongoing hope of a return for the midfielder. However, the article admits a January departure from Newcastle seems unlikely.
Tonali’s ability to adapt and thrive in a new role could make him indispensable to Newcastle’s midfield evolution. Yet, for now, his perceived “reserve” status remains a talking point, leaving fans and pundits alike questioning how Eddie Howe plans to maximize the potential of his £55 million man.
